Clinical Article
Myocardial Perfusion in Patients With Total Occlusion of a Single Coronary Artery With and Without Collateral Circulation
Maged El-Gantiry; Salah El-Din Hamdy Demerdash; Mona Rayyan; Ramy Raymond; Wael El-Naggar; Nabil Farag; Mohamed El-Ramly; Sameh Thabet and Amr Hassan, MD.
Background: Previous
studies that investigated the effects of coronary collateral circulation on
myocardial perfusion were compromised by inclusion of patients with multivessel
coronary artery disease, incomplete occlusion, prior myocardial infarction, or a
combination of these.
Methods: In this study we
will investigate the relationship between angiographic collateral circulation
and myocardial perfusion in patients with total occlusion of a single coronary
artery, in the absence of myocardial infarction or significant stenosis in the
other coronary arteries supplying the same myocardial territory.
Results: Forty patients
underwent stress myocardial single photon emission computed tomography within 90
days of angiography. Collateral circulation was present in 24 patients (Group A)
and absent in 16 patients (Group B). Reversible perfusion defects were present
in 22 (91.7%) patients in group A and in 12 (75%) in group B, comparison between
both groups came back statistically insignificant (p-value=NS). Group A included
4 (18.2%) patients with a small size defect (<5%), 9 (40.9%) patients with a
moderate perfusion defect (5-10%) and 9 (40.9%) patients with a large perfusion
defect (>10%); while group B had 2 (16.6%) patients with small perfusion defect,
5 (41.6%) patients with a moderate perfusion defect and also 5 (41.6%) patients
with a large perfusion defect, comparison between both groups came back
statistically insignificant (p-value=NS). The mean exercise time for patients in
group A was 6.9±0.92 minutes and their mean achieved peak METs was 7.35±0.35
METs. On the other hand; the mean exercise time for patients in group B was
6.9±0.83 minutes and their mean peak METs was 7.23±0.25 METs. Comparison between
both groups also appeared to be statistically insignificant (p-value=NS).
Conclusions: In patients
with a single-vessel total coronary occlusion and without myocardial infarction,
stress-induced myocardial ischemia is almost always present, irrespective of
presence or absence of angiographic collaterals. These data suggest that
coronary collaterals do not appear to protect against stress-induced perfusion
defects. Nevertheless collaterals in our study did not have any positive impact
on the functional capacity of patients, predicted by the analysis of exercise
duration and achieved peak METs.
Keywords: Coronary artery
total occlusion, Collateral circulation, Myocardial perfusion, CTO.
(Heart Mirror J 2009; 3(2): 80-85)